Guide

Traffic Dropped After a Website Redesign: What to Check

A redesign can change URLs, content, links and crawl access in one release. Check each of those against the launch date and you will usually find the cause.

If traffic dropped after a website redesign, the cause is usually one of five things: old URLs that no longer redirect, URLs that changed, content that was cut or rewritten, pages blocked from Google, or internal links that were lost. Compare the date of the drop with the launch date, then check those five in order.

How to tell the redesign caused it

Open Search Console and look at the Performance report. Set the date range to include a month either side of launch. If clicks fall on or within a few days of launch, and the fall touches most pages, the relaunch is the prime suspect.

Be careful about coincidence. A Google core update can land in the same weeks as a launch. Our guide on how to tell if a Google update hit your site shows how to separate the two. A redesign drop tends to follow your launch date. An update drop follows Google's rollout dates.

The five checks, in order

First checks

Five things to check first

Run these in this order. The first two cause the biggest losses and are the easiest to prove.

If you find a fault in step one, fix it before looking further. A broken redirect map can explain the whole drop.

Redesign drop checklist

  • Old URLs redirect to the right new pages
  • Important URLs kept or mapped
  • Robots, noindex and canonical rules are clean
  • Content on key pages was not cut
  • Internal links to key pages still exist

1. Redirects from old URLs

Take your old URL list from a backup, an old sitemap, or the Pages and Performance reports in Search Console. Test whether each old URL answers with a permanent redirect to the matching new page. Common faults are old URLs returning 404, redirecting to the homepage, or passing through several redirects in a row. Our guide to redirect mapping for a site migration explains how to build the map properly.

2. URL changes

If the redesign changed paths, folders or parameters, Google treats the new addresses as new pages. Each one needs to earn its place again unless a redirect carries the old signals across. Where possible, keep the old URL structure.

3. Crawl and index rules

Check robots.txt for a leftover disallow rule from staging. Check page source for a noindex tag. Look at the canonical tag on key pages, which may point to the wrong version. The Pages report in Search Console lists excluded URLs and the reason, which makes a blocked site obvious.

4. Content on the pages that ranked

Compare the old and new version of your top pages. Look for shortened copy, removed headings, text moved behind tabs, product descriptions replaced by images, or whole pages merged. If the pages that lost the most are the ones whose content changed most, you have your cause.

Menus, footers and category pages decide which pages get internal links. A new navigation can leave your best pages with almost none. Our guide to internal linking for recovery shows how to audit and repair this.

Other causes worth ruling out

Page speed and rendering matter too. A new front end that loads content with JavaScript can leave Google seeing an empty page, which our guide on JavaScript SEO rendering problems explains. Tracking can also break, so confirm the drop appears in Search Console and not only in your analytics.

How to fix it

Fix in order of damage. Repair redirects first, then crawl rules, then restore content and links on the pages that lost the most. Request indexing for the key fixed pages with the URL Inspection tool, and keep your XML sitemap current with the new URLs. Then track clicks for the old pages and their new equivalents, so you can see whether each group is coming back.

Nobody can tell you the exact recovery date, because Google has to recrawl and reprocess the changes. Some sites recover most of what they lost. Some recover part, because the new site really is different. Our website migration SEO recovery page sets out how we judge those odds, and our answer on whether a redesign can hurt SEO covers the basics.

If you are about to relaunch, work through our SEO migration checklist first.

When to call for help

Get help when you cannot match the old and new URLs, when the site has thousands of pages, or when you have fixed the obvious faults and nothing has moved. Those signs mean the diagnosis is incomplete.

We start with the evidence: the launch date, the old and new URL lists, and what changed on the pages that lost. Ask for a free SEO triage and send us the launch date.

FAQ

Questions owners ask us

Should I roll back the redesign?

Not before you know what broke. Most redesign drops come from a few fixable faults. A rollback changes the site again, which can add to the confusion for Google. Find the cause first, then decide.

Is a small dip after launch normal?

Some movement while Google reprocesses a changed site is common. A drop that is steep, sudden or still getting worse after a few weeks is a sign something is broken. Compare the dip against the launch date and the pages that lost.

What if my URLs did not change?

Then look at content, internal links, page speed, rendering and indexing rules. Pages can lose rankings even when the address stays the same, if the text, headings or links around them changed.

Get started

Tell us where it hurts.

Your site, what changed and when. We reply with a first read on the cause.